(2018) 4 Visn. Nac. akad. prokur. Ukr. 117–129
doi
Title of the article Dermatoglyphics in Pre-trial Investigation
Author(s) OLEKSANDR IZOTOV
PhD in Law, Docent, senior lecturer, department of continuous training of military prosecutors, Institute for Continuing Professional Development, National Prosecution Academy of Ukraine, Kyiv, Ukraine, alex.izprok@gmail.com
HANNA HANOVA
PhD in Law, Docent, senior lecturer, department of continuous training of military prosecutors, Institute for Continuing Professional Development, National Prosecution Academy of Ukraine, Kyiv, Ukraine, ganova@ukr.net
Short title
of the journal (ISSN)
Visn. Nac. akad. prokur. Ukr.
Year 2018
Issue 4
Pages [117–129]
Language Ukrainian
Abstract Since forensics became science a lot of forensic means and methods have been developed, as well as results of research in other sciences, in particular medicine, psychology, logic, anthropology, mechanics, optics, etc. have been borrowed, modernized, and successfully used in counteraction to crime. This approach aims at solving two important tasks of criminal offences investigation: the unmistakable identification of a person on his/her individual characteristics; search for a criminal based on the study of traces left on the crime scene.
Dactyloscopy, being the process of comparing two instances of friction ridge skin impressions, is still considered to be one of the most reliable means of person identification. However, the methods used by criminals, e.g. the ways of changing and falsifying fingerprints, as well as individual features of a person, are always improving. Therefore, forensic experts are forced to use, along with fingerprinting, methods of another science – dermatoglyphics, which have been successfully used in medicine, psychology, and anthropology. The affinity of fingerprinting and dermatoglyphics is obvious, since they have a common subject of study – human skin. Unfortunately, Ukrainian specialists almost do not study these issues, therefore domestic practices of crime counteraction do not have developments in this sphere.
The purpose of the article is to outline some recommendations on application of dermatoglyphics in pre-trial investigation of criminal offences.
The authors highlight some important issues in pre-trial investigation, which can be solved using dermatoglyphics. In particular, they argue the possibility to trace the race or ethnicity of a person, the blood relations between close relatives, the identification of unidentified corpses, the establishment of individual characteristics of a person. Recommendations on the application of dermatoglyphics achievements in establishing the psychological characteristics of the suspect with a view to choosing the tactics of his/her search, detention, interrogation, conducting an investigative experiment with his/her participation, and other procedural actions are also proposed.
According to the results of the study, the authors state that traditional methods of identifying a person are weaker than modern, sophisticated, based on different characteristics of the human body. So, in the opinion of the authors of the article, the recommendation to create the new type of examination – dermatoglifical – is useful.
Keywords criminal offence; pre-trial investigation; fingerprints; human skin; dermatoglyphics; identifi cation of a person.
References REFERENCES
List of legal documents
Authored books
1. Okros Sandor, The Heredity of Papillary Patterns (Akademiai Kiado, Publishing House of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences 1965) 174 (in Hungarian).
2. Jedzhubov L и Bogdanov N, Papilliarnye uzory: identifikatsiia i opredelenie harakteristik lichnosti (Daktiloskopiia i dermatoglifika) [Papillary Patterns: Identification and Characterization of Personality (Dactyloscopy and Dermatoglyphics)] (Jurist 2002) 28 (in Russian).
3. Jedzhubov L, Poljakov V i Eliseev V, Statisticheskaia daktiloskopiia. Metodicheskie problemy [Statistical Fingerprinting. Methodical Problems] (Gorodets 1999) 131 (in Russian).
4. Obozov N, Psihologicheskaia kultura vzaimnyh otnoshenii [Psychological Culture of Mutual Relations] (Vysshaia shkola 1986) 24 (in Russian).
5. Saltevskyi M, Kryminalistyka (u suchasnomu vykladi) [Criminalistics (Modern Presentation)] (Kondor 2008) 142–3 (in Ukrainian).
Edited books
6. Sedova A ta Jeksarhopulo A (ed), Kriminalistika [Forensic Science] (Lan 2001) 118 (in Russian).
Journals articles
7. Bogdanov N, Samishhenko S i Hvylja-Olinter A, ‘Dermatoglifika serijnyh ubiits’ [‘Dermatoglyphics of Serial Killers’] (1998) 4 Voprosy psihologii 61–7 (in Russian).
8. Cummins H, ‘Dermatoglyphic Stigmata in Mongoloid Imbeciles’ (1939) 73 Anatomical Record 407–15 (in English).
9. Mishalov V ta Kozan N, ‘Suchasnyi stan problemy identyfikatsii zahalnykh fenotypichnykh oznak liudyny za dermatohlifi chnymy parametramy kysti ta stopy’ [‘The Current State of the Problem of Identifying Common Phenotypic Features of a Person According to Dermatoglyphic Parameters of the Hand and Foot’] (2013) 1 Sudovo-medychna ekspertyza 4–9 (in Ukrainian).
10. Pashkova Yu, Palahniuk H ta in, ‘Novyi pohliad na dermatohlifiku yak metod diahnostyky hipertonichnoi khvoroby’ [‘A New Look at Dermatoglyphics as a Method of Diagnosing Hypertension’] (2015) 3(75) Bukovynskyi medychnyi visnyk 237–9 (in Ukrainian).
11. Vlasov A, ‘Opredelenie tipa temperamenta po uzoram papilljarnyh linij’ [Determining the Type of Temperament by Patterns of Papillary Lines’] (2012) 1 Molodoi uchenyi 51–3 (in Russian).
Dissertations
12. Badikov K, ‘Stanovlenie i perspektivy razvitiia dermatoglifiki v kriminalistike’ [‘Formation and Development Prospects of dermatoglyphics in Forensic Science’] (diss kand jurid nauk, Dalnevostochnyi gosudarstvennyi universitet 2002) 235 (in Russian).
13. Jarovenko V, ‘Problemy primeneniia dermatoglifi cheskih issledovanii v kriminalistike’ [‘Problems of Application of Dermatoglyphic Research in Forensic Science’] (diss d-ra jurid nauk, Uralskaia gosudarstvennaia juridicheskaia akademiia 1996) 350 (in Russian).